Should a D2C brand sell on Amazon? The correct answer depends on your category, your brand stage, and your long-term strategy. The wrong answer is "we will not sell on Amazon because we want to be D2C purists" when Amazon captures 40 percent of your category's search volume. Here is the strategic framework for making this decision correctly.
The Core Amazon Trade-Off
Amazon gives you: access to 150 million Prime subscribers, built-in trust infrastructure, and purchase velocity that generates reviews quickly. Amazon takes from you: customer relationship data (you cannot retarget Amazon buyers with Klaviyo), brand control (your product appears next to competitor products and private label alternatives), and significant margin (Amazon fees total 15 to 25 percent plus fulfilment costs if using FBA).
The question is not Amazon versus your own site. It is whether Amazon's contribution to your total revenue and brand awareness justifies its costs. For most D2C brands, the answer is: Amazon for discovery and volume, own site for customer relationship and LTV. These are not competing channels. They serve different purposes in your growth strategy.
When Amazon Accelerates D2C Growth
Review velocity: Amazon's review system generates reviews faster than most D2C direct programmes. A product with 200 Amazon reviews is more credible to a new customer discovering you on any channel, including your own website. Brands that use Amazon specifically to build review velocity for a new product launch, then shift focus to direct, use the channel strategically rather than dependently.
Discovery for new brands: if nobody knows your brand exists, Amazon's search algorithm can introduce you to buyers who are actively searching your category. This works best for brands with a genuinely differentiated product that stands out in Amazon search results. Commodity products without meaningful differentiation get crushed by the Amazon private label algorithm.